Explain their relative ionising effects with reference to: (a) kinetic energy (b) electric charge

Resources | Subject Notes | Physics

IGCSE Physics - 5.2.2 Nuclear Emission

IGCSE Physics - 5.2.2 The three types of nuclear emission

This section explains the three main types of nuclear emission: alpha decay, beta decay, and gamma decay. We will focus on understanding their relative ionising effects, considering both kinetic energy and electric charge.

1. Alpha Decay

Alpha decay occurs when an unstable nucleus emits an alpha particle, which is equivalent to a helium nucleus ($^4He$).

Ionising Effect

Alpha particles are relatively heavy and have a positive charge (+2). This makes them highly ionising.

Kinetic Energy: Alpha particles are emitted with high kinetic energy. This high energy allows them to readily knock electrons off atoms in the surrounding material, creating positive ions and free electrons. The higher the kinetic energy, the greater the ionising effect.

Electric Charge: The +2 charge of the alpha particle significantly contributes to its ionising power. The positive charge attracts the negatively charged electrons in atoms, leading to their removal.

2. Beta Decay

Beta decay occurs when a neutron in the nucleus transforms into a proton, emitting an electron (beta particle) and an antineutrino.

There are two main types of beta decay: beta-minus ($^14C \rightarrow ^14N + e^- + \bar{\nu}_e$) and beta-plus ($^22Na \rightarrow ^22Ne + e^+ + \nu_e$).

Ionising Effect

Beta particles are electrons (beta-minus decay) or positrons (beta-plus decay). They are much lighter and have a single negative (beta-minus) or positive (beta-plus) charge.

Kinetic Energy: Beta particles are emitted with varying kinetic energies, typically lower than alpha particles. Their ionising effect is therefore less pronounced than that of alpha particles.

Electric Charge: The charge of a beta particle is either -1 or +1. While they do attract electrons, their lower mass means they are less effective at removing electrons compared to the heavier, more charged alpha particles.

3. Gamma Decay

Gamma decay occurs when an unstable nucleus emits a high-energy photon, known as a gamma ray ($ \gamma $). This does not change the number of protons or neutrons in the nucleus.

Ionising Effect

Gamma rays are electromagnetic radiation and have no mass or charge. They are highly penetrating and can ionise matter through three main processes:

  • Photoelectric effect: A gamma ray interacts with an electron, ejecting it from the atom.
  • Compton scattering: A gamma ray collides with an electron, losing some energy and changing direction. The electron is also ejected.
  • Auger electrons: A gamma ray interacts with the nucleus, creating a pair of electrons (Auger electrons) which then ionise the surrounding material.

Kinetic Energy: Gamma rays carry a significant amount of energy, which can be transferred to electrons and atoms, leading to ionisation.

Electric Charge: Since gamma rays have no charge, they do not directly attract or repel charged particles. Their ionising effect is solely due to their high energy.

Relative Ionising Effects

Emission Type Relative Kinetic Energy Relative Electric Charge Relative Ionising Effect
Alpha ($^4He$) High $ +2 $ Highest
Beta ($e^- \text{ or } e^+$) Medium $ -1 \text{ or } +1 $ Medium
Gamma ($\gamma$) High 0 Lower than Beta, but higher than Alpha

Conclusion: Alpha particles have the highest ionising effect due to their high mass, high charge, and high kinetic energy. Gamma rays have a lower ionising effect than alpha and beta particles because they are uncharged and have lower mass, although they carry high energy. Beta particles have an ionising effect intermediate between alpha and gamma decay.

Suggested diagram: A diagram showing alpha, beta, and gamma particles with labels indicating their charge, mass, and relative ionising effect.