The allocation of resources - Mixed economic system (3)
Resources |
Revision Questions |
Economics
Login to see all questions
Click on a question to view the answer
1.
The government provides subsidies to the renewable energy sector. Discuss two potential benefits and two potential drawbacks of this policy. Consider the impact on consumers, businesses and the government.
Potential Benefits:
- Environmental Benefits: Subsidies encourage the development and adoption of renewable energy sources like solar and wind power. This reduces reliance on fossil fuels, leading to lower carbon emissions and mitigating climate change.
- Economic Growth & Job Creation: The renewable energy sector is a growing industry. Subsidies can stimulate investment and innovation in this sector, leading to job creation in manufacturing, installation, and maintenance.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Cost to Taxpayers: Subsidies for renewable energy require significant government funding, which ultimately comes from taxpayers. This can lead to higher taxes or cuts in other public services.
- Distortion of Market Efficiency: Subsidies can distort the market by artificially lowering the price of renewable energy. This may hinder the development of more cost-effective renewable energy technologies and could lead to inefficient allocation of resources. It may also protect less efficient renewable energy companies from competition.
2.
The government takes control of an industry or company from private owners. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of nationalisation. (12 marks)
Nationalisation is a policy where the government assumes ownership and control of key industries or companies previously owned by the private sector. This can be a significant intervention in the economy, with both potential benefits and drawbacks.
Advantages of Nationalisation:
- Reduced Inequality: Nationalisation can lead to a more equitable distribution of wealth and income. Profits can be reinvested in the country, benefiting all citizens.
- Improved Public Services: The government can prioritize public good over private profit, leading to better quality services (e.g., healthcare, utilities) and more affordable prices.
- Economic Stability: Nationalisation can provide stability to industries, protecting jobs and preventing closures due to market fluctuations. The government can also plan for long-term investment.
- National Objectives: The government can direct industries towards national goals, such as national security or infrastructure development, which might be neglected by private companies focused solely on profit.
Disadvantages of Nationalisation:
- Reduced Efficiency: Lack of profit motive can lead to inefficiency, bureaucracy, and poor management. This can result in lower productivity and higher costs.
- Lack of Innovation: Without competition, there is less incentive for innovation and improvement in products and services.
- High Costs to the Government: Nationalisation often requires significant government investment, which can strain public finances. The government may need to compensate former owners, adding to the cost.
- Political Interference: Government control can lead to political interference in business decisions, potentially hindering economic efficiency.
Conclusion: Nationalisation is a complex policy with significant potential benefits and drawbacks. Its success depends on effective management, strong political will, and a clear understanding of the industry's specific needs. The potential for reduced inequality and improved public services must be weighed against the risks of inefficiency and political interference.
3.
Describe the role of government in a mixed economy. Include specific examples of government intervention and explain the rationale behind these interventions.
The government plays a crucial and multifaceted role in a mixed economy. Its interventions are designed to correct market failures, promote social welfare, and ensure economic stability. The rationale behind these interventions is to improve upon the outcomes of a purely free market, addressing issues of inequality, instability, and inefficient resource allocation.
Specific Examples of Government Intervention and Rationale:
| Cell | Description & Rationale |
| Taxation | The government levies taxes (income tax, corporation tax, VAT) to generate revenue for public services and to redistribute income. Rationale: Funding public goods, reducing inequality, and influencing economic behaviour (e.g., discouraging smoking through higher taxes on tobacco). |
| Regulation | The government sets rules and regulations for businesses to protect consumers, workers, and the environment. Rationale: Preventing monopolies, ensuring product safety, protecting workers' rights, and mitigating pollution. |
| Provision of Public Goods | The government directly provides goods and services that the market would under-provide, such as national defence, law and order, and infrastructure. Rationale: Ensuring essential services are available to all citizens, promoting national security, and facilitating economic activity. |
| Welfare Programs | The government provides social welfare programs (e.g., unemployment benefits, healthcare, housing assistance) to support vulnerable individuals and families. Rationale: Reducing poverty, promoting social stability, and ensuring a minimum standard of living. |
These interventions are not always without debate. There are ongoing discussions about the optimal level of government intervention and the potential trade-offs between efficiency and equity. However, the role of government in a mixed economy is generally accepted as essential for a stable and prosperous society.