Consumer and producer surplus (3)
Resources |
Revision Questions |
Economics
Login to see all questions
Click on a question to view the answer
1.
Question 1: Define producer surplus and explain how it can be illustrated graphically. Discuss two factors that might affect the size of producer surplus.
Definition: Producer surplus represents the difference between the total revenue producers receive from selling a good or service and the minimum price they are willing to accept. It's essentially the benefit producers gain from supplying the market.
Graphical Illustration: Producer surplus is illustrated on a supply and demand diagram as the area above the supply curve and below the market price. This area represents the surplus producers enjoy because they sell at a price higher than their marginal cost of production.
Factors Affecting Producer Surplus:
- Changes in Demand: An increase in demand will typically lead to a higher market price. This higher price increases producer surplus because producers can sell their goods at a more profitable price. Conversely, a decrease in demand will reduce producer surplus.
- Changes in Costs of Production: A decrease in the costs of production (e.g., cheaper raw materials, more efficient technology) will increase the profitability of producing the good. This allows producers to be more willing to supply at lower prices, potentially increasing producer surplus. An increase in costs will reduce producer surplus.
- Government Intervention: Government interventions like price ceilings (which prevent prices from rising) can reduce producer surplus. Price floors (which set a minimum price) can increase producer surplus, but only if the market price is above the floor.
2.
The government introduces a price ceiling on a particular good. Using supply and demand diagrams, explain the likely consequences of this policy for both consumer surplus and producer surplus. Discuss the potential benefits and drawbacks of price ceilings.
Consequences of a Price Ceiling:
Diagram: (A diagram should be included here showing a supply and demand curve with a price ceiling set below the equilibrium price. The diagram should clearly show the reduction in quantity traded, the creation of a shortage, and the areas representing changes in consumer and producer surplus.)
Consumer Surplus: A price ceiling typically leads to an increase in consumer surplus. Because the price is artificially restricted, consumers who are willing to pay more than the ceiling price can now purchase the good at a lower price. This results in a larger area representing consumer surplus.
Producer Surplus: A price ceiling generally reduces producer surplus. Producers are now restricted from charging the higher prices they would have charged in the free market. This reduces their profitability and leads to a smaller producer surplus.
Benefits of Price Ceilings:
- Increased Affordability: Price ceilings make goods more affordable for consumers, particularly those with lower incomes.
- Social Welfare: They can improve social welfare by ensuring access to essential goods.
Drawbacks of Price Ceilings:
- Shortages: Price ceilings often lead to shortages, as the quantity demanded exceeds the quantity supplied.
- Black Markets: Shortages can create black markets where the good is sold illegally at prices above the ceiling.
- Inefficiency: Price ceilings can distort market signals and lead to inefficient allocation of resources.
Therefore, while price ceilings can benefit consumers in the short term, they often have unintended consequences and can be economically inefficient.
3.
Question 1
The diagram below shows the supply and demand curves for a particular product.
A change in consumer surplus is illustrated.
(a) Explain, using the diagram, how a change in demand can cause a change in consumer surplus.
(b) Discuss the factors that might cause a change in demand for this product.
(c) Using the diagram, show how a change in consumer surplus is related to a change in producer surplus.
(a) Consumer surplus is the difference between what consumers are willing to pay for a good and what they actually pay. A change in demand affects consumer surplus by altering the quantity demanded at each price level.
- An increase in demand leads to a higher equilibrium price and quantity. Consumers are willing to pay more and the quantity they buy increases, resulting in a larger consumer surplus.
- A decrease in demand leads to a lower equilibrium price and quantity. Consumers are willing to pay less and the quantity they buy decreases, resulting in a smaller consumer surplus.
The diagram shows that an increase in demand shifts the demand curve to the right, leading to a higher equilibrium price and quantity. This results in a larger area representing consumer surplus.
(b) Factors that might cause a change in demand include:
- Changes in consumer income (normal goods). An increase in income increases demand.
- Changes in consumer tastes and preferences. A new health trend might increase demand for organic food.
- Changes in the price of related goods. If the price of a substitute good increases, demand for the original good increases.
- Changes in consumer expectations about future prices. If consumers expect prices to rise, demand increases now.
- Changes in the demographics of the population. An aging population might increase demand for healthcare products.
(c) Consumer and producer surplus are related because a change in consumer surplus often leads to a change in the equilibrium price and quantity. This, in turn, affects the producer surplus.
- An increase in consumer surplus (due to increased demand) typically leads to a higher equilibrium price. This increases producer surplus as producers receive a higher price for their goods.
- A decrease in consumer surplus (due to decreased demand) typically leads to a lower equilibrium price. This decreases producer surplus as producers receive a lower price for their goods.
The diagram illustrates this relationship – a shift to the right in demand increases both consumer and producer surplus.