Exchange rates (3)
Resources |
Revision Questions |
Economics
Login to see all questions
Click on a question to view the answer
1.
The following diagram shows the demand and supply for a currency in the foreign exchange market. Assume the exchange rate is initially fixed at £1.20 per unit. Explain, using the diagram, the difference between a revaluation and a devaluation of the fixed exchange rate. Discuss the likely impact on the UK's exports and imports.
[Insert a simple demand and supply diagram here showing a fixed exchange rate and arrows indicating revaluation and devaluation. The diagram should clearly label axes, curves, and the initial fixed rate.]
Revaluation of a Fixed Exchange Rate: A revaluation occurs when the government decides to raise the fixed exchange rate. This means the currency becomes more valuable in relation to other currencies. In the diagram, a revaluation is represented by shifting the supply curve to the right. This indicates that the country is willing to supply more of its currency at any given price (exchange rate).
Impact on Exports and Imports (Revaluation):
- Exports: A revaluation makes UK exports more expensive for foreign buyers. This is because foreign buyers now need to spend more of their currency to buy the same amount of UK goods. As a result, the quantity of UK exports will likely decrease.
- Imports: A revaluation makes imports cheaper for UK consumers and businesses. UK buyers can now buy more foreign goods with the same amount of UK currency. Therefore, the quantity of UK imports will likely increase.
Devaluation of a Fixed Exchange Rate: A devaluation occurs when the government decides to lower the fixed exchange rate. This means the currency becomes less valuable in relation to other currencies. In the diagram, a devaluation is represented by shifting the demand curve to the left. This indicates that the country is willing to supply less of its currency at any given price.
Impact on Exports and Imports (Devaluation):
- Exports: A devaluation makes UK exports cheaper for foreign buyers. Foreign buyers can now buy more UK goods with the same amount of their currency. As a result, the quantity of UK exports will likely increase.
- Imports: A devaluation makes imports more expensive for UK consumers and businesses. UK buyers need to spend more of their currency to buy the same amount of foreign goods. Therefore, the quantity of UK imports will likely decrease.
In summary, a revaluation tends to reduce exports and increase imports, while a devaluation tends to increase exports and decrease imports. The overall impact on the UK's balance of payments depends on the relative magnitudes of these effects.
2.
Question 2
Consider a small, open economy. Explain how the adoption of a crawling peg exchange rate system might benefit the economy. Discuss the potential risks associated with this system.
A crawling peg is a type of fixed exchange rate system where the value of the currency is adjusted periodically in relation to another currency or basket of currencies. The adjustment is typically gradual and predetermined, hence the term "crawling."
- Benefits:
- Gradual Adjustment to Economic Changes: Allows the exchange rate to adjust gradually to changes in economic fundamentals, such as inflation or trade imbalances. This reduces the risk of large, disruptive exchange rate movements.
- Maintains Competitiveness: The gradual appreciation or depreciation of the currency can help to maintain competitiveness in international markets. A depreciation can boost exports, while an appreciation can help to control inflation.
- Credibility: A well-managed crawling peg can enhance a country's credibility with international investors.
- Risks:
- Requires Credibility and Commitment: The crawling peg system requires the central bank to maintain credibility and commitment to the adjustment path. If investors lose confidence, they may launch speculative attacks.
- Potential for Misalignment: If the adjustment path is not properly calibrated, the exchange rate may become misaligned with economic fundamentals.
- Limited Monetary Policy Independence: While greater than a fixed peg, the central bank still has limited monetary policy independence as it must manage the exchange rate.
For a small, open economy, a crawling peg can be a useful tool for managing exchange rate volatility and maintaining competitiveness. However, it requires careful management and a strong commitment from the central bank.
3.
Question 3
Evaluate the effectiveness of exchange rate policy in addressing balance of payments problems. Consider the advantages and disadvantages of both fixed and floating exchange rate systems in this context. Provide examples to support your answer.
Exchange rate policy plays a crucial role in addressing balance of payments (BOP) problems, which arise when a country's exports are less than its imports. The effectiveness of exchange rate policy depends heavily on the exchange rate system in place.
Fixed Exchange Rate Systems: Under a fixed exchange rate, the central bank can intervene in the foreign exchange market to maintain the value of the currency.
- Advantages:
- Automatic Correction: A depreciation of the currency can make exports more competitive and imports more expensive, helping to improve the trade balance. This is an automatic correction mechanism.
- Discourages Speculation: A fixed exchange rate can discourage speculative attacks on the currency.
- Disadvantages:
- Requires Large Foreign Reserves: The central bank must hold large foreign reserves to defend the fixed exchange rate.
- Limited Flexibility: The central bank has limited flexibility to respond to changing economic conditions.
Floating Exchange Rate Systems: Under a floating exchange rate, the exchange rate is determined by market forces.
- Advantages:
- Automatic Adjustment: The exchange rate can adjust to absorb trade imbalances. A depreciation will improve the trade balance.
- No Need for Foreign Reserves: The central bank does not need to hold large foreign reserves.
- Disadvantages:
- Volatility: Exchange rate volatility can create uncertainty for businesses and investors.
- Can Exacerbate Problems: A sharp depreciation can worsen trade imbalances.
Examples:
System | Effectiveness in Addressing BOP Problems |
Fixed | Can be effective if the currency is overvalued. Requires significant foreign reserves and can be vulnerable to speculative attacks. Historically, many countries have struggled to maintain fixed exchange rates successfully. |
Floating | Generally effective as the exchange rate will adjust to absorb trade imbalances. However, the adjustment can be slow and volatile. |
In conclusion, exchange rate policy can be an effective tool for addressing BOP problems, but the choice of exchange rate system is crucial. A floating exchange rate system generally provides more flexibility and is better suited to absorbing trade imbalances, while a fixed exchange rate system can be effective if the currency is overvalued and the central bank has sufficient reserves and credibility.