2.1.2 Employment contracts and legal controls over employment issues (3)
Resources |
Revision Questions |
Business Studies
Login to see all questions
Click on a question to view the answer
1.
A company is considering introducing a new policy regarding holiday entitlement. The current policy states that employees accrue holiday days proportionally to their length of service. The proposed new policy would reduce the amount of holiday entitlement for employees who have been with the company for less than 2 years. Discuss the potential legal and ethical considerations for the company in implementing this new policy. Consider the potential impact on employee morale and productivity.
The company must carefully consider the legal and ethical implications of reducing holiday entitlement, particularly for employees with less than two years of service. Several factors need to be addressed:
Legal Considerations:
- Statutory Holiday Entitlement: The company must ensure that the new policy does not fall below the statutory minimum holiday entitlement (5.6 weeks per year). Any reduction below this would be illegal.
- Contractual Obligations: The new policy could be considered a breach of contract if it reduces holiday entitlement for employees who are already covered by a contract that specifies a certain amount of holiday.
- Fair Discrimination: The policy could be challenged as unfair discrimination if it disproportionately affects certain groups of employees (e.g., those with less experience).
Ethical Considerations:
- Employee Morale: Reducing holiday entitlement can negatively impact employee morale, leading to decreased job satisfaction and motivation. Employees may feel undervalued and resentful.
- Productivity: Reduced holiday can lead to burnout and decreased productivity in the long run. Employees need time off to rest and recharge.
- Fairness and Equity: The policy raises questions of fairness and equity. It may be perceived as unfair to penalize employees who are relatively new to the company.
- Reputation: Implementing a policy that reduces holiday entitlement can damage the company's reputation as an employer.
Potential Impact on Morale and Productivity:
The policy is likely to have a negative impact on employee morale and productivity. Employees may feel demotivated, stressed, and less committed to their work. This can lead to increased absenteeism, lower quality work, and higher staff turnover. The company needs to carefully weigh the potential benefits of the policy (e.g., cost savings) against the potential negative consequences.
2.
Consider Sarah, who has recently started working as a marketing assistant for a small business. Her employment contract states that she is required to work 9am to 5pm, Monday to Friday, with one hour for lunch. She is entitled to 25 days of holiday per year. The contract also specifies that she receives sick pay for the first 7 days of illness, after which she receives statutory sick pay. Discuss the potential implications for Sarah if her employer attempts to change her working hours without her agreement. What legal rights does Sarah have in this situation?
If Sarah's employer attempts to change her working hours without her agreement, several implications could arise. Firstly, the employer may be in breach of contract. The agreed working hours are a key term of her employment, and unilaterally changing them could be considered a breach. This could lead to legal action from Sarah.
Sarah has several legal rights in this situation:
- Right to Refuse: Sarah has the right to refuse to work outside of the agreed hours. She is not obligated to accept changes to her contract without her consent.
- Potential Breach of Contract: If Sarah is forced to work outside of the agreed hours without her agreement, it constitutes a breach of contract by the employer.
- Redundancy: If the change in working hours is linked to a restructuring or redundancy situation, Sarah may have rights under redundancy law.
- Unfair Dismissal: If the employer attempts to dismiss Sarah because she refuses to work outside of her agreed hours, this could be considered unfair dismissal.
- Negotiation: Sarah should attempt to negotiate with her employer to reach a mutually acceptable solution. This could involve discussing alternative arrangements or seeking compensation for the change in hours.
The specific legal rights available to Sarah will depend on the circumstances and the applicable employment law in her jurisdiction. She may need to seek advice from a trade union or employment solicitor.
3.
An employer and employee need to agree on the terms of employment. Discuss the key elements that are typically included in a formal employment contract. Explain why it is important for both the employer and the employee to have a clear, written employment contract.
A formal employment contract outlines the terms and conditions of the employment relationship. Key elements typically include:
- Duties and Responsibilities: A clear description of the tasks the employee is expected to perform. This may include specific job duties, reporting lines, and performance expectations.
- Working Hours: Details the agreed start and end times, including any overtime arrangements. This may specify a fixed schedule or flexible working options.
- Holiday Entitlement: Specifies the statutory minimum holiday entitlement (e.g., 5.6 weeks per year in the UK) and any additional holiday provisions.
- Sick Pay: Outlines the employer's policy on sick pay, including the amount of pay received during sickness and any requirements for medical certificates.
- Salary and Payment Terms: Specifies the agreed salary, frequency of payment (e.g., weekly, monthly), and any bonus or commission structures.
- Probationary Period: Details the length of the probationary period and the conditions under which the employment can be terminated during this time.
- Confidentiality and Intellectual Property: Clauses protecting the employer's confidential information and ownership of any intellectual property created by the employee during their employment.
- Termination Clause: Specifies the procedures for terminating the employment relationship, including notice periods.
It is crucial for both parties to have a written contract because it provides clarity and avoids misunderstandings. It establishes a legally binding agreement, protecting the rights of both the employer and the employee. A clear contract reduces the potential for disputes and ensures both parties understand their obligations. It also provides evidence in case of a disagreement or legal action.